Issue #3 · 2026-11-16
Correction: Naspers and Prosus didn't sink the JSE today
What we got wrong, and what actually moved
Naspers (NPN) closed at 73,550c, up 1.40% on the day. Prosus (PRX) closed at 66,758c, down a mild 0.42% (source: Sharenet, closing prices). Meanwhile the Nasdaq Composite kept falling through the US afternoon — down 2.63% to 24,475.81 as of 1:35pm ET, deeper than when Issue #2 was written (source: Yahoo Finance). If Naspers/Prosus were transmitting the Nasdaq's chip-sector pain to the JSE, you wouldn't see this: SA's two biggest tech-adjacent counters barely moved while US tech kept sliding.
So what actually dragged the FTSE/JSE All Share Index to its -0.77% close? Anglo American (AGL), one of the index's largest resources counters, closed down 2.50% to 82,579c — a far bigger single-day move than anything in the tech space (source: Sharenet). The JSE's weakness today looks like a resources story, not a tech story.
Does this undo yesterday's retirement-fund point?
No — but it sharpens it. Issue #2's argument was about the offshore portion of a Regulation 28 retirement fund: the global equity trackers that many SA retirement annuities use for their offshore allocation are concentrated in the same handful of US chip and AI names that sold off hard today. That's still true, and today's Nasdaq close (-2.63%, deepening through the session) didn't change it.
What today adds is the other half of the picture: the local portion of a typical SA retirement fund isn't automatically diversified away from concentration risk either. The JSE All Share is heavily weighted toward a handful of resources counters — Anglo American among the largest — so a bad day for diversified mining can move the whole local index on its own, independent of whatever's happening to US tech. 'Global equity for offshore, JSE for local' isn't a free diversification lunch on either side; each half has its own concentration story.
This is the kind of self-correction we'd rather make explicitly than quietly drop. If a thesis from a previous issue doesn't hold up against the next day's numbers, that goes in the next issue — not just the next private spreadsheet.
What to watch next
Nvidia reports Q3 FY2027 earnings after this issue goes out — the release that both Issue #1 and Issue #2 flagged as the next real test of whether today's chip selloff was a governance overreaction or a fair repricing.
Thursday, 19 November 2026: SARB MPC rate decision, still the headline domestic event this week.
Worth checking if you hold SA unit trusts: what share of your 'local equity' allocation sits in resources specifically — it's a different concentration question from the offshore one, but just as relevant after today.
Get the free daily brief
Weekday email, after the issue is published. The same brief as the site. Free.